When we think about success in law enforcement, we often picture flawless execution, perfect decisions, and unwavering confidence. But what if we told you that some of the most successful law enforcement professionals—the ones making a real difference in their communities and their own lives—got there by failing, learning, and trying again?
That's the real story of failing forward.
Failing forward isn't about celebrating mistakes or treating failure like success. It's about extracting every lesson from a setback, making meaningful improvements, and coming back stronger. It's the difference between repeating the same mistake over and over (which, as the saying goes, is the definition of insanity) and using failure as fuel for growth.
On the latest episode of The Blah, Blah, Blah…Something Wellness Podcast, host Tami Sharp, alongside partners Chris Zamora, and guests John Kelly, Vince Scott, Mike Riley, and Tiffany Graaff—all veterans of law enforcement with decades of collective experience—dive deep into what it really takes to fail forward and why this skill is critical for first responder success.
The conversation opened with raw, relatable stories from the field. Vince Scott shared a humorous but telling story from his early days as a cop in New York City. Working in Greenwich Village, he and his partner heard a guttural scream and ran to investigate, thinking they'd found a robbery in progress. In his youthful excitement, Vince swung his mag light—only to discover it wasn't a perpetrator he was striking, but two civilians in an intimate moment.
"I was embarrassed," Vince recalls. "And my mind's racing a million miles per hour."
What did he learn? To slow down. To think before reacting. To understand that what you see might not be what it actually is.
For 30 years, this moment followed Vince. Every time he saw the friends he worked with, they'd laugh and ask, "Who are we going to say hit him?" But here's the important part: that failure never defined him. It refined him. It became a story about growth, not shame.
But personal resilience only goes so far. John Kelly, a 30-year veteran and founder of a life leadership wellness program, made a crucial point: leadership has to allow people to fail.
"If you fail at something and then you're written up, benched, suspended—the walls start falling in," John explained. "There's no lesson learned. There's no opportunity to grow."
When officers are punished rather than coached through their mistakes, they don't learn—they shut down. They stop asking for help. They stop reaching out. And that's when real damage happens.
John knows this firsthand. He showed up to work intoxicated during his career. Rather than firing him, his department saw opportunity. They got him help, set him up with resources, and gave him a chance to recover. That single act of grace—of choosing investment over punishment—changed the trajectory of his life and career.
Today, John is a leader in the wellness space, helping officers across the country. His second career exists because someone believed in him during his failure.
Mike Riley, a retired NYPD lieutenant and current coach, shifted the conversation to something deeper: the difference between identity and role.
"My identity has never changed," Mike shared, reflecting on his career transition. "The roles have."
When Mike retired from the NYPD after an on-duty injury a month before his captain's exam, he fell into a dark place. His entire identity was wrapped up in being a cop. But after years of coaching and personal development, he realized something crucial: his values of service, commitment, and leadership had nothing to do with any particular uniform or position.
That realization freed him. He started volunteering at his kids' school, founded a stop-and-drop program, joined the school board, and eventually became a state-elected official.
"Nineteen years ago, if you told me I'd be doing this when I retired from the police department, I would have said there's no way," Mike said. "And the reason why I share that is my identity has never changed. The roles have."
For first responders, this is critical. When your identity is tied only to your job, every failure at work feels like a failure of self. Divorce, trauma, line-of-duty injuries, missed promotions—these aren't just professional setbacks. They feel existential. And when that's the case, officers stop reaching out for help. They spiral.
The conversation then shifted to something rarely discussed in police academies: relationships.
John brought the statistics into sharp focus: For every bad guy that kills one of us, two to three of us take our own lives. Half the time, that suicide is connected to a divorce or relationship breakup.
"We know statistically that failing in a relationship is statistically going to be the thing that allows you to take your own life," John said bluntly. "And yet we refuse to acknowledge that statistic, and we don't provide any training to make you a better spouse."
Think about that. We train officers endlessly on tactical skills, traffic stops, investigations—things they'll do hundreds of times in their career. But we don't train them on the one skill that statistically matters most: how to maintain a healthy relationship while carrying the weight of law enforcement.
Chris Zamora emphasized this point by walking through an exercise he uses in training. He plays the role of a sergeant asking a young officer to hold over for overtime—once, twice, three times, four times. By Friday, he asks the officer to stay late instead of date night with their spouse.
When Chris asked the spouse how she felt, she said one word: "Neglected."
"And the look on his face," Chris recalled, "he had no clue. Because what he saw was 'I'm a dedicated cop.' In the meantime, he's ignoring his family life."
Here's the thing: that young officer wasn't wrong to be dedicated. But dedication to the job at the expense of the marriage doesn't lead to success. It leads to resentment, distance, and eventually, divorce.
Vince Scott brought up something that's been eating at him for years: the support systems exist, but officers don't use them. Why?
"There's a trust issue," Vince said simply. "A trust issue from the top down to the bottom up."
If you fall and no one in your agency is going to be there to pick you up, why would you tell anyone anything?
Vince spent years carrying bitterness about the people he worked with. He felt unsupported and unappreciated by colleagues, and that feeling leaked into his personal life. It created cynicism. It kept him isolated. It wasn't until years later, on the other side of his police career, that he realized the damage: he had healed, but he never fully healed. He'd put band-aids on open wounds instead of actually addressing them.
The lesson? Self-awareness matters, but so does the environment. If an officer can't trust their agency, they won't access the resources, even if those resources are excellent.
So how do we actually fail forward? The panel offered a clear framework:
Test. Try something new. Take the risk. Apply for that promotion. Reach out to that coach. Try that communication technique with your spouse.
Learn. When you fail, don't just move on. Extract the lesson. What went wrong? What would you do differently? Tiffany Graaff mentioned a powerful technique: break down the rumination. Was it social embarrassment? Self-worth? A fear of not belonging? Often, the failure itself triggers an old script—an old belief about yourself—and that's worth exploring.
Improve. Don't re-enter with the same approach. Make the adjustment. Try a different angle. Build on what you learned.
Mike Riley emphasized this during the conversation: "If we fail, we got to learn from it. But then this is the key piece here: Improve. Don't just say, 'Oh, I made that mistake,' and re-enter. Improve how you are going to make that second attempt."
One of the most powerful moments in the conversation came when Vince shared something personal: in his divorce, he questioned himself as a father. He ruminated. He carried shame. But someone told him, "Don't let them live rent free in your head," and that changed everything.
That's the work. Not avoiding failure. Not hiding it. But acknowledging it, learning from it, and choosing not to let it define you.
"If we're able to acknowledge our own individual vulnerability and recognize, okay, I'm not going to be perfect," Vince said. "There will come times when I do make mistakes. To acknowledge it, learn from it, but then take action steps to evolve. Not point fingers, because we're in a career where everyone's pointing the finger. We failed to realize we're not infallible. There's a vulnerability piece to that."
Tami Sharp closed the conversation with a powerful reframe: rejection sometimes is for your protection.
If you didn't get that promotion, that might be the best thing that could have happened to you. If that relationship didn't work out, that might have been necessary. If that business failed, it might have redirected you to exactly where you needed to be.
Law Enforcement Coaching's first business attempt failed. And because of that failure, the coaching practice that exists today—the one helping officers across the country—was born.
"I'm so thankful for that failure. So protected. So thankful," Tami reflected.
If you're a first responder struggling with a failure—whether it's a professional mistake, a relationship breakdown, an addiction issue, or an identity crisis—know this: you're not alone. Every officer on that podcast panel has been there. And every single one of them came through the other side.
The resources mentioned in the episode include:
If you're ready to fail forward, the first step is reaching out. Connect with a coach, a mentor, a therapist, or a peer support officer. Let someone help you extract the lesson from your setback and build something stronger.
Because that's what failing forward is really about: not avoiding failure, but refusing to let it stop you.