Schedule a Discovery Call

Not Everything Needs to be an IA:

Solving Problems Before They Become Formal Investigations

Some police problems can be solved by a sergeant having a hard conversation. Not everything needs to become an Internal Affairs investigation. But law enforcement culture has created a system where anything uncomfortable automatically escalates to formal discipline—which destroys trust, drives wedges between officers, and prevents actual problem-solving.


The Over-Investigation Problem: Why Departments Go Straight to IA

The impulse is understandable: you have a problem, so you involve Internal Affairs. But this creates a culture where officers hide problems instead of solving them.

Marlon Marrache, known as "The IA Guy" with 24 years in LAPD, sees this every single day:

"The first thing people want to do is open an IA case. But not everything is an IA matter. Some things are management issues. Some things are training issues. Some things are communication issues that need to be solved at the sergeant level."

When everything becomes an IA case, you're sending a message: "We don't trust you to solve your own problems. We're going to investigate you instead."

Greg Nottingham, 31 years with Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, describes what happens next:

"You open an IA case, and now an officer is lawyering up. They're defensive. They're not communicating. The problem isn't being solved; it's being frozen in legal proceedings for months while everyone waits."


What's Actually an IA Matter?

Internal Affairs exists for a reason: criminal conduct, policy violations that create liability, abuse of power, corruption. Not for every human conflict.

Marlon breaks down the real categories:

This is an IA Matter:

  • Criminal conduct (assault, theft, DUI)
  • Abuse of power (searching someone's home without cause)
  • Corruption (taking bribes, selling information)
  • Discrimination or harassment that creates a hostile work environment
  • Dishonesty (falsifying reports, lying under oath)

This is NOT an IA Matter (It's a Management Issue):

  • Two officers aren't getting along
  • A supervisor is being too harsh or too lenient
  • Communication broke down
  • Someone made a tactical mistake (unless it endangered someone)
  • Poor customer service (unless it's part of a pattern of discrimination)
  • Bad attitude or insubordination (which is a training/counseling issue)

"If you can solve it with a good sergeant having a hard conversation, it's not an IA matter."


The Sergeant's Job: Having the Hard Conversation

Most problems in police departments can be solved by a sergeant who's willing to have an uncomfortable conversation.

Kevin Mede, 25 years with Whatcom County Sheriff's Office and Wellness Program Director, sees sergeants avoiding this responsibility:

"A sergeant has to be willing to pull someone aside and say, 'Here's what I'm seeing. Here's what needs to change. Here are the consequences if it doesn't.' That's management. That's what you get paid to do."

This conversation looks like:

Step 1: Private Pull the officer aside. One-on-one. Not in front of others.

Step 2: Clear Describe exactly what you observed and why it's a problem.

Step 3: Direct "This needs to change. Here's how we're going to fix it. Here's what I need from you."

Step 4: Follow Up Check in. See if behavior changed. If it didn't, escalate.

This is not IA. This is management.


When Problems Escalate: The Chain Before Investigation

Before IA, there are steps. Skip those steps, and you've weaponized the system.

Mike Lawson, San Diego Sheriff's Deputy and Chula Vista Wellness Coordinator, describes the chain:

Step 1: Sergeant Intervention Hard conversation. Clear expectations. Follow-up.

Step 2: Lieutenant Involvement If the sergeant level didn't work, the lieutenant gets involved. More formal, but still not IA.

Step 3: Documentation At this point, document what you've tried, what's changed (or not), and why escalation is necessary.

Step 4: IA Only after management has failed, and there's actual policy violation or misconduct.

"Too many departments skip steps 1-3 and go straight to IA. That's when you lose the opportunity to actually change behavior."


The Cost of Over-Investigation: What Happens to Officers Under IA

Being under investigation is traumatic. It's adversarial. It assumes guilt and requires proof of innocence.

Marlon Marrache has been on both sides. He knows what it does to officers:

"Once you're in the IA system, your assumptions change. You assume everyone is working against you. You stop trusting your chain of command. You lawyer up. You stop communicating. The culture of trust is broken."

This is especially damaging for minor issues:

"I've seen IA investigations opened for something that could have been solved in a 15-minute conversation. By the time the investigation closes, the officer is damaged. The trust is gone. The department has spent six months and thousands of dollars to solve something that needed a manager, not an investigator."


The Retaliation Trap: Why Officers Don't Report Problems

If every mistake becomes an IA case, officers stop reporting problems early. They hide them.

Eric Tung, 18 years with Western Washington PD and Patrol Commander, sees this pattern:

"Officers don't report issues early because they know it's going to become an IA case. So they hide things, and then the problem gets bigger, and when it finally surfaces, it's worse."

This is the worst possible outcome: officers self-governing by silence.

Solution: Create a reporting system that isn't automatically adversarial. Officers can report problems to their supervisor, to a chaplain, to a peer-support officer, or to an IA investigator—with different outcomes:

  • Supervisor: coaching and management
  • Chaplain/Peer Support: confidential assistance
  • IA: only if there's actual misconduct

How to Tell When Something Really Needs IA

Ask these questions:

  1. Is there criminal conduct involved? (IA)
  2. Is there abuse of power? (IA)
  3. Is there dishonesty or deception? (IA)
  4. Is this a pattern, not a one-time mistake? (IA)
  5. Could this expose the department to major liability? (IA)

If you answer "yes" to any of these, call IA.

If you answer "no" to all of them—you have a management problem. Handle it at the sergeant or lieutenant level.


Building a Culture Where Problems Get Solved, Not Buried

The goal is officers who communicate problems early because they know they won't be destroyed for it.

This requires:

1. Clear Definition of What's an IA Matter

Everyone knows the line. If it's below the line, it's handled at the management level.

2. Safe Reporting

Officers can report problems to their sergeant, to a chaplain, to peer support—with different levels of confidentiality and action.

3. Swift Resolution at the Right Level

Minor stuff gets resolved in days or weeks by a manager. Major stuff goes to IA.

4. Follow-Up

After a sergeant conversation, you check in. You see if behavior changed. You follow through.

5. Protection Against Retaliation

Make it clear: if someone reports a problem or is involved in a situation that gets reported, retaliation is IA-level misconduct.


Key Takeaways: Matching the Problem to the Right Solution

  1. Not everything is an IA matter. Reserve IA for criminal conduct, abuse of power, dishonesty, and patterns of serious misconduct.
  2. Most problems are management issues. A sergeant should be able to have a hard conversation and resolve it.
  3. Escalate through the chain. Sergeant → Lieutenant → IA. Skip steps, and you're weaponizing the system.
  4. Being under investigation is traumatic. Use IA for serious misconduct, not as a management tool.
  5. Officers hide problems when everything becomes an IA case. Create a reporting system with different outcomes based on severity.
  6. Document the process. When you involve a sergeant, document what was said and what changed. This creates a record if escalation is needed.
  7. Clear definitions matter. Everyone—from recruits to commanders—should know what crosses the line into IA territory.
  8. Swift resolution prevents damage. The faster a problem is addressed at the right level, the less damage it does to culture and trust.

Related Podcast Episodes

Episode 7: Not Everything Needs to Be an IA
Featuring: Tami Sharp, Greg Nottingham, Kevin Mede, Mike Lawson, Eric Tung, Marlon Marrache
Aired: July 18, 2025

🎧 Listen on Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube

This is part of the "Navigating Toxic Work Environments" series. Each episode features law enforcement leaders discussing what actually creates toxic cultures—and what's actually working to break the cycle.

Watch the Full Episode Here

crossmenu